Wreck of the Mentor Reviews

Reviews for Wreck of the Mentor

"Lovers of Dad books rejoice! Here is the historical nautical book of the summer"--Book Riot

The NEW YORK TIMES has selected THE WRECK OF THE MENTOR as one of the most anticipated nonfiction books of 2026! The title of the article is "The Nonfiction Everyone Will Be Talking About in 2026." Click on the underlined title above to read the article.

Goodreads selection as Readers’ Most Anticipated Books of Summer…and the Rest of the Year!

Barnes & Noble selection as One of the Best Books of June 2026

Amazon Editor's Pick for Best History

Amazon pick for Best Nonfiction and History Books of June 2026

Amazon pick for "Best Books of the Year so Far, 2026"

Lit Hub's Ultimate Summer Reading List

Number 5 on the list of nonfiction books The New York Times readers are most excited about this summer

Christian Science Monitor chooses it as one of the best books of June

BOOKSAMILION chooses it as one of the 2026 History and Current Events Books you need to read.

Kirkus selection as one of the 40 Hottest Reads for Summer of 2026

BookBub's list of "The Must-Read Non-Fiction of the Summer"

The mariners’ story—headline news at the time but largely forgotten since—is resuscitated in Eric Jay Dolin’s The Wreck of the Mentor. Mr. Dolin is an experienced hand at nautical adventure; this is his 17th book. In addition to recounting an exciting and at times almost unbelievably dramatic story, the author helps readers appreciate how Western visitors affected the delicate balance of power among indigenous cultures. The Wreck of the Mentor makes for less-guilty adventure reading, depicting a scenario where the odds were leveled by circumstance. —Michael O’Donnell, Wall Street Journal

With The Wreck of the Mentor, Eric Jay Dolin once again demonstrates why he has become one of today's leading maritime history authors. Echoing the survival narrative of his acclaimed Left for Dead: Shipwreck, Treachery, and Survival at the Edge of the World (2024), this latest work explores another remarkable survival story from the Age of Sail. . . . [In exploring the motivations and perspectives of the various actors] he transforms what might have been another dramatic tale of shipwreck into a thoughtful work of maritime and cross-cultural history. . . . If you are looking for a thrilling survival-after-shipwreck story, you will certainly find one here, but you will also discover something more--a nuanced exploration of human nature, cultural encounter, and resilience under extraordinary circumstances."—Deirdre O'Regan, Sea History Magazine

Yes, this is the story of a ghastly shipwreck: The 84-foot-long US whaling vessel Mentor broke apart on a reef on the Pacific archipelago of Palau ten months after setting sail in 1831. But veteran maritime writer Eric Jay Dolin gives us so much more. The Wreck of the Mentor is a gorgeously illustrated, rip-roaring drama artfully enriched with subtle anthropological insights. . . . Of the 22 officers and crew who embarked in New Bedford, Massachusetts, eager to share the spoils of the whaling trade, only 7 survivors returned to the United States. The final stragglers had been away for four years. They lived through a gruesome ordeal, one we share with them in this vivid and engrossing story.—Alex Beam, Yale Alumni Monthly

If there was ever a book, ever an author, who can write history and immediately absorb a reader’s complete attention, it’s Eric Jay Dolin and his soon to be released historic story, The Wreck of the Mentor. . . . [The] Mentor is a captivating, true, full of detail story of a 19th century shipwreck of a whaling ship that sailed out of New Bedford Harbor in Massachusetts bringing investors as well as sailors to wealth in the Pacific ocean. . . . The book isn’t necessarily pretty … but neither is life. There are tribal wars, plenty of fighting with axes, clubs, spears and anything else handy, and the crushing stories of how survival is won. Even when it’s painful, a reader cannot stop reading until he has seen what happens next. Dolin makes history thrilling! The book is bound to be a smashing hit once it hits the shelves in June, so those who love maritime stories, history, heroes and cowards, love and culture should put their orders in now for the June release. Oh, yes, of course there is a naval rescue! It’s a true story.

—Muriel J. Smith, Veni Vidi Scripto

A vivid castaway story. From the Odyssey to Lord of the Flies, the shipwreck genre may be the world’s oldest, and few readers will object to this addition from best-selling maritime historian Dolin. High-seas adventures that’ll keep readers hungrily turning the pages. —Kirkus Reviews

I have read a lot of books on nautical history over the past 20 years, and one thing I can always count on -- if it's written by Eric Jay Dolin, it's going to be good. . . . What follows is a thorough -- and thoroughly enjoyable -- recounting of the fates of the captain and crew of the Mentor, along with several asides about the native populations of those islands and their customs, as well as other shipwrecks and encounters with the inhabitants in that region of the Pacific. The author packs a lot of information into this book, which is a fairly fast read at just over 200 pages, but it never reads like a dry history text. Dolin has a gift for transforming the nuts and bolts of our nautical past into thrilling adventure, and he doesn't disappoint here. . . . It's unlikely you'll finish The Wreck of the Mentor with very many questions ... except possibly, "When does Dolin's next book come out?" Few historians bring their stories to life so deftly, and anyone captivated by tales of the sea should definitely check him out.—Tom Knapp, Rambles.net

Eric Jay Dolin brings this long-forgotten story back into the public eye. The author of 17 books that have largely focused on maritime history, he is a talented researcher and natural storyteller. . . . Dolin’s masterful storytelling is on full display as he details how the

shipwrecked men faced indecision, intrigue and sheer terror in a part of the world they barely knew. . . . The Wreck of the Mentor is a fascinating adventure story – one which the Age of Sail produced few quite like. Dolin’s keen observational eye will ensure that it will never be forgotten again.— Michael Taube, The Spectator

Eric Jay Dolin delivers a masterful account of the 1832 wreck of the American whaleship Mentor, a disaster that shattered not only the vessel but the very social order aboard it. . . . Drawing from archival sources, logs, journals, oral histories, and Indigenous accounts, the narrative transcends the typical shipwreck story. It becomes a study in human resilience and the breakdown of maritime hierarchy, where authority dissolves and survival becomes the castaways’ only goal. The author’s meticulous research brings depth to the sometimes
convoluted yet tragic tale, illuminating the psychological and cultural consequences of contact between vastly different worlds. . . . The result is a compelling and often harrowing narrative that challenges romanticized portrayals of maritime adventure. It reframes the reader’s understanding of hardship, survival, and cultural encounter during one of the most volatile periods of Pacific exploration. . . . Eric Jay Dolin’s latest work stands as yet another excellent contribution to maritime history – one that will resonate with readers interested in the human dimensions of historical catastrophe.— Louis Norton, The Northern Mariner

"Dolin (Black Flags, Blue Waters), a prolific author of acclaimed maritime, environmental, and wildlife titles, presents the harrowing saga of the 22 men aboard the whaling ship Mentor. . . . Engaging and well-written, this will appeal to readers with an interest in maritime history and the real-life adventures of seafarers." -- Margaret Kappanadze, Library Journal

"Stories about sailors facing danger are remarkably popular. The Wreck of the Mentor by Eric Jay Dolin fits squarely in this genre. The book hits all the points that make stories about sailors in peril so compelling. The Wreck of the Mentor reminds us about the unimaginable challenges many early Americans faced and the tenacity they demonstrated in overcoming them." — Terry W. Hartle, Christian Science Monitor

Eric Jay Dolin's The Wreck of the Mentor is the story of one ship's end that is also a fine introduction to maritime life of the early to mid-19th century. With its backdrop of berths and hulls, rudders, staysails, and waistboats, Dolin's book fits right in with the other recent chronicles of watery disasters, from David Grann's The Wager to Hampton Sides' The Wide Wide Sea. But The Wreck of the Mentor is not just for readers already committed to oceanic history. Dolin's exploration of the catastrophe, which details the lives of sailors shipwrecked in the Micronesian islands, offers an in-depth understanding of the impact whaling had on the 19th-century world. This story stretches all the way from Nantucket to Palau and, eventually, as far as showman P.T. Barnum's stage. —Eliza McGraw, American Heritage

"Dolin’s storytelling is smooth, easy, and instantly engaging, and he includes the essential reference of a nice map. . . . The Wreck of the Mentor is a good overview of an important time in world history, when Western commercial fleets were sailing the world, spreading attitudes and technology and injecting elements of political economy into realms such as Palau, whether it was wanted there or not. It opens the door to a further reading list of published primary sources fundamental to understanding the development of Western influences in the Pacific and the results of that influence.—Michael Dyer, Wooden Boat

"Dolin weaves it all into a dark adventure that must be read to be believed, along within the larger story of the history of whaling, exploration, and sailing. The lavish illustrations add depth to the engaging prose. Reaching far beyond a simple shipwreck chronicle, Dolin's latest dramatic account is a compelling addition to maritime history collections."— Booklist

The Wreck of the Mentor flows with a novel’s alacrity while anchored by meticulous research and sound documentation. And it reaches well beyond the tale of a shipwreck. The Wreck of the Mentor, abundantly well illustrated, is yet another masterful maritime history from Eric Jay Dolin’s pen.— George D. Jepson, Quarterdeck

"In The Wreck of the Mentor, award-winning author Eric Jay Dolin brings to life an astounding saga of maritime perils, the desperation of basic survival, and encounters with unknown --- and sometimes unknowable --- tribal people. . . . Dolin has produced numerous, well-received and award-winning works focused on maritime history. In THE WRECK OF THE MENTOR, he accompanies his vivid saga with photographs, a comprehensive collection of notes, and translations of some of the indigenous languages that its central characters encountered, all of which underpins this highly recommended narrative."— Barbara Bamberger Scott, Bookreporter

Back to Wreck of the Mentor